Are cities too clean, too predictable and ultimately too smart for their own good? Taking Korea’s Songdo as an example, Adam Scott from FreeState, and Global Head of Design at HASSELL tells us how we might just be missing the mark when it comes to planning a city.
The rationale of the ‘Smart’ as a means for improving, designing and building our cities has reached a tipping point of acceptability. Indeed, such is the take-up rate among urban planners that we are today returning to the age of the emperors, one where it is possible – and for some desirable – to design and populate a city from scratch, the most obvious example being South Korea’s Songdo, the world’s so-called smartest city. Unfortunately, as enamoured as we are by our technological prowess, we are in danger of losing sight of what cities are all about: the experiences of people being people.
A dystopia
From the perspective of the urban planners’ spreadsheet, it’s easy to see why Songdo might appeal. Built on reclaimed land outside Seoul, it is a year zero, purpose-built city; a clean, super-connected mega-sized business district that its planners say borrows from the best of the world’s greatest cities. It has its own Venetian canal system and central park. It’s underpinned by a package of ‘smart services’ managing everything from the home to traffic to health. It’s made for an environmentally sustainable community. It offers, in the words of one of its key IT providers, “the ultimate lifestyle and work experience.”
However, like the branded cities of old built by kings as singular testaments to their omniscient powers, Songdo is also the result of a fundamental misunderstanding of what it takes for a city to be a city. A joint venture between American developers, South Korean constructors and local government, it mistakes people for categories of users, re-imagining the experiences of financiers, technologists, bio-pharmacists, commuters, residents, patients and relaxers as part of a vast and predetermined system of input-output solutions, one so technologically advanced as to have done away with the need for ‘3-D’ or ‘dirty’, ‘dangerous’ or ‘difficult’ industries. Largely bereft, therefore, of the messiness of manufacturing and municipal service industries, of crowds, of dirt, and of the organic and often anarchic growth of the street, it is an invention dedicated to an ‘international community’ of ‘forward-thinking individuals and companies’. It’s so clean – safe and predictable – as to be hyper-hygienically unnatural. It’s not home. It’s a technocrat’s wet dream – had in the 1950s.
Insert human
Much like how technologists tend to champion the democracy of the internet, advocates of the smart city speak of the equality of access and opportunity, strategically prioritising technical platforms, infrastructure, project development and information systems in the name of tens of thousands of projected users. Songdo IBD (the city’s local authority) takes it a step further, speaking of creating “an unparalleled quality of life as technology, resources and innovation come together to create a world class international community.”
Leaving aside the moral implications of its somewhat rarefied class of desirable citizens, Songdo’s philosophy for city building begins with the absence of that which makes a city a city: the human. Cities do not ‘create’ communities. People form communities, and cities – as the lead developer of Kings Cross Central Argent St George stated in its Principles for a Human City (2000) – are where people do life. And by people, it means everyone who has any interest – past, present or future – in the city, which is why before making any plans for what would become a fiendishly complex project, Argent’s chief executive Roger Madelin would meet 7,500 people at 353 different meetings, to which he travelled on his bicycle.
It’s worth pausing for a moment on this, the image of the head of one of the world’s leading developers cycling about a rundown piece of London to listen to the experiences, views and ideas of thousands of its people. Compare this to the relatively people-less top of the value stack that serves as the Smart strategy for a city like Songdo. Indeed, compare it with the consultation process that goes into any large urban development. In a recent piece of research envisioning the themes for the strategic framework for the development of Brisbane’s Southbank, the difference between what we imagined people wanted and what we discovered by getting out from behind our desks and asking was startling: while we came up with a set of well-meaning, positive and worthy themes, the people who live, work and regularly visit Southbank wanted something much more subversive, underground and risky.
Roger Madelin’s 353 meetings served as the evidence base for the philosophy of principles that sees Kings Cross Central having become – 17 years later – exactly what it set out to be: ‘a public piece of London’, a mixed use quarter, home to two schools, a university, a cookery school, a mobile urban garden, 2,000 new homes (a staggering 50 per cent of which are affordable housing), and 24 acres of open space. This from a man on a bicycle whose vision was informed by listening to the very people his work would directly affect. Cities, lest we forget, begin with people.
Photography by Robert Stainforth/Alamy
Adam Scott is a user experience design specialist at FreeState (which recently merged with HASSELL). Read Scott’s full article here.
A searchable and comprehensive guide for specifying leading products and their suppliers
Keep up to date with the latest and greatest from our industry BFF's!
Viccarbe’s design furniture concepts draw inspiration from the vibrant spirit of Valencia and have revolutionised interiors across the globe. Featuring celebrated designers such as John Pawson and internationally acclaimed collections, Viccarbe offers a contemporary perspective on modern commercial and residential spaces.
Didier studio celebrates the harmony of democratic design and understated utility with the Gunzel seating and table collection.
Lizzy Stageman blends ancestral wisdom with artistry to reveal grand life stories in her contemporary Aboriginal designs. ‘Finding My Place’ transforms her original art into captivating commercial textiles, wall coverings & acoustic art.
With this smart and forward-looking renovation of a 30-year-old Singaporean public housing flat, STUDIO WILLS + Architects topped INDE.Awards 2019 Living Space category, partnered by Gaggenau.
Open plan and flexible workspaces have become the catchcry for contemporary office design. However, Sound Cloud, a tech company specialising in audio streaming services, not only achieves this criteria but also importantly produces a sound-friendly environment.
The internet never sleeps! Here's the stuff you might have missed
Graduates’ portfolios embodied their commitment to harnessing design as a force for social improvement at the DIA’s Graduate of the Year Awards 2023.
It’s been a busy month as usual across the design industry in Australia and the wider Asia Pacific. We track the latest promotions and moves.
Sydney Design Week 2023, themed ‘Amodern’ in honour of Bruno Latour, offers a diverse program of over 60 events across the city. We highlight three standout events at the intersection of design, culture and consciousness.
The DIA has made an urgent call to arms to interior designers, proposing that the profession urgently needs to be considered for licensing under the NSW Building Bill 2023 to allow interior designers to practice in their full capacity.